YIMBY Law sued Los Angeles for refusing to process a 60-unit apartment building at 5353 Del Moreno Drive at the density allowed by the city's general plan, insisting instead on a rezoning. The Superior Court ruled for housing in July 2022, confirming that the Housing Accountability Act requires cities to allow development at general plan densities even where zoning allows less.
At the Superior Court July 29, 2022
You can read the Superior Court’s decision here, and the Court’s judgment here. The City of LA has 60 days to follow the Housing Accountability Act which in this case means they have to process AJ’s application for an apartment building, and approve it at the density proposed by AJ and allowed in the general plan. The city is also barred from requiring rezonings for projects which conform to the densities allowed in the city’s Limited Commercial land use designation.
The statewide import of this is significant. All over California there are areas where the general plan allows higher - sometimes much higher - densities than the zoning allows. This is another confirmation that state law does in fact require cities to follow the density allowed in their General Plans.
In 2018 legislators passed a very powerful amendment to the Housing Accountability Act. It requires cities to allow housing developments at the density that is allowed in the General Plan, even if the zoning only allows lower densities. Unfortunately, LA is ignoring this new law.
Part of the reason this policy is so necessary is that the Housing Element is part of the General Plan, and one of the ways that cities frustrate the Housing Element process is they will designate certain areas as high density in their Housing Element, but then contradict that density in their zoning.
In this case, the general plan plus density bonus allows a 60 unit apartment building, but the zoning allows only a single family house, and, weirdly, a chinchilla farm.
The project sponsor, Akhilesh Jha, came to the United States in 1998 from Bihar in India. He received a PhD from Virginia Tech and had a successful career in the aerospace industry. After 20 years, he decided to change careers, and apply his skills and work ethic to building housing. Despite ongoing, repeated discouragement from the Planning Department in LA, AJ was confident that his interpretation of the state law was correct, and that the City of LA is required to approve his proposal for an apartment building in a single family zone. AJ called us at YIMBY Law and we were able to confirm that we believe his interpretation is correct.
We at YIMBY Law couldn’t be more excited to (finally) have an opportunity to challenge Los Angeles’ manifestly illegal interpretation of the HAA. They are simply ignoring the law. Read our petition here, and check back for updates.
Project approvals & streamlining
The rules for saying yes: the Housing Accountability Act, permit deadlines, ministerial approval, vesting rights, and the limits on hearings and delay.
Zoning & density
What cities may zone for and how much: density bonus, duplexes and lot splits, transit-oriented density, ADUs, parking reform, and downzoning fights.
Know a compliant housing proposal that’s being blocked? That’s how our cases start.