YIMBY Law defended The Olivia, an 81-unit 55+ community with 7 very low income units, after the Clayton Planning Commission denied its State Density Bonus application over subjective complaints like a four-parking-spot shortfall. Following YIMBY Law's letters citing state law, the Clayton City Council rejected the commission's position and approved the project 3-2 on March 3, 2020.
Approved! 3-2, March 3, 2020
The proposal: 74 market rate and 7 very low income units for a total of 81 apartments for residents 55 years and older.
On December 10, 2019, The Clayton Planning Commission denied a State Density Bonus application for the “The Olivia,” an 81-unit senior community with 7 units designated for very low income units. State law, however, is clear: cities cannot impose subjective reject density bonus concessions that would make an otherwise zoning-compliant project financially unfeasible.
The Housing Accountability Act prohibits cities from denying projects based on subjective criteria when they otherwise comply with zoning rules at the time of application. Without it, anti-housing jurisdictions can drag out decisions and stall projects with little to no evidence for their concerns. State Density Bonus law also bars cities from applying design standards to projects that would make it impossible for the developers to break even.
The Olivia submitted its first applications more than two years before the December 10 decision and, at the time, the city found no evidence that the project was inconsistent with the “objective standards” in its zoning codes. We wrote two letters to the City of Clayton informing them of their obligations under state law.
Yet when the project finally came before the Planning Commission, the commissioners had a laundry list of subjective complaints—and no evidence to back them. Among them, the project would supposedly impact available parking in the area. The project only planned to include 86 parking spots, but the Commission wanted 90. So they denied the Density Bonus Application. You read that right: the Clayton Planning Commission wanted to violate state law and deny housing to 81 seniors over four parking spots.
On March 3, 2020, the Clayton City Council denied the Planning Commission’s appeals of the project.
Update from YIMBY Law
Approved! 3-2 March 3, 2020.
Project approvals & streamlining
The rules for saying yes: the Housing Accountability Act, permit deadlines, ministerial approval, vesting rights, and the limits on hearings and delay.
Zoning & density
What cities may zone for and how much: density bonus, duplexes and lot splits, transit-oriented density, ADUs, parking reform, and downzoning fights.
Know a compliant housing proposal that’s being blocked? That’s how our cases start.