YIMBY Law, the California Housing Defense Fund, and Californians for Homeownership are suing San Francisco over its Family Zoning Plan, arguing the rezoning violates state housing law and the city's own adopted Housing Element. The suit says the plan falls far short of the 36,000 units of capacity the city promised and illegally tries to opt out of state housing statutes.
Filed petition on February 12, 2026
Next: · Wednesday · Hearing
We, along with California Housing Defense Fund and Californians for Homeownership, have filed a lawsuit against San Francisco over its recently adopted Family Zoning Plan, which violates California housing law, contradicts the city’s own adopted Housing Element, and fails to deliver the housing capacity the city promised to allow.
In 2023, the City of San Francisco adopted a new housing element, which promised that the City would enact new policies to facilitate the production of more housing as a way to address the “state of affordability crisis… felt by low-, moderate-, and, more recently, middle-income households.” San Francisco promised to rezone large areas of the city to allow for greater residential development and that the rezoning would provide enough new capacity to accommodate more than 36,000 new housing units by 2031.
When the deadline to enact this rezoning arrived, the City reneged on its promise and instead enacted the Family Zoning Plan, which violates state law in several key ways:
San Francisco must bring its zoning code into compliance with state housing law and its adopted Housing Element, and to invalidate provisions that illegally attempt to preempt state housing statutes.
Filed petition on February 12, 2026
Housing elements & fair share
State-mandated housing plans and the fair-share duties behind them: site inventories, the builder's remedy, regional housing targets, and their counterparts outside California.
Zoning & density
What cities may zone for and how much: density bonus, duplexes and lot splits, transit-oriented density, ADUs, parking reform, and downzoning fights.
Project approvals & streamlining
The rules for saying yes: the Housing Accountability Act, permit deadlines, ministerial approval, vesting rights, and the limits on hearings and delay.
Know a compliant housing proposal that’s being blocked? That’s how our cases start.